Prairie Guest House

Award-winning Fishers, IN B&B & event center near Conner Prairie. Whole-house rental available.

10 rooms

Member since 2026

Stay for the Story

Set on two acres in Fishers, Indiana, Prairie Guest House is a mid-1800s Gothic farmhouse offering 10 guest suites, an early-1900s cottage, and a barn backdrop used for weddings, retreats, and micro-events - with the option to rent the entire property. Innkeepers John and Karen Newton, recipients of Indiana's Hoosier Hospitality Award, serve a scratch-made breakfast daily. The inn sits directly adjacent to the Conner Prairie outdoor museum, 30 minutes from downtown Indianapolis.

Amenities, Service and Experiences

Biking
Breakfast Available
Concierge Services
Full House Rental Available
Hidden Gem
LGBTQI+ Friendly

Packages and Special Offers

Friends Fall 10% Discount

Prairie Guest HouseFishers, IN

We are offering our friends of Select Registry a special discount when you visit this fall. By the way this is my favorite time of year here in Central Indiana. Sweaters, sun, and lots of farmers markets and festivals. Let us know when you're planning on being here and we will be sure to hold a room for you. PROMO CODE: friends

Expires: Nov 23, 2026See Details

Local Dining

Sahm's Restaurant

Sahm's Pub - Our local favorite. Always good, always served with a smile. Family friendly with daily rotating specials. Five Stars!

Matteo's Ristorante Italiano

Mateo's - Get your Italian favorites here. On the courthouse square in Noblesville. Great experience excellent food. Pasta will make you smile.

Peterson's

Peterson's Steak House - Incredible fresh food, delivered with excellent service. Wide ranging menu accommodates everyone. You will love it!

Local Activities

Conner Prairie

Conner Prairie is an interactive museum of living history. Smithsonian Affiliate, full of adventures for all. Stay with us right across the street.

Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts

The Palladium hosts hundreds of events each year, featuring the best in classical, jazz, pop, rock, country, & comedy. Get tickets stay with us.

Hamilton County Tourism

Historic Noblesville is 5 minutes up the street. Great for shopping, dining, and people watching. Really great walking trails nearby too.

Reviews

"We had the best time!"

— Darlene Argeropolos

4.9351 reviews

5 star

4 star

3 star

2 star

1 star

Guest reviews mention

cozy rooms25wedding venue23beautiful property19kind owners18comfortable bed16spacious rooms13bridal shower9quiet rooms5

351 reviews

Darlene Argeropolos15 hours ago

5/5

We had the best time! John and Karen are amazing and did everything to make our stay so special. This resort is absolutely beautiful, breakfasts were always a nice surprise, and the rooms were beautifully decorated. Loved the place. Hope to return next year. 😊❤️

Peter Shadeka week ago

5/5

My wife and I had a wonderful stay at Prairie Guest House this past weekend. John and his wife have a charming inn and made us feel comfortable and at home immediately. Their attention to detail is impeccable and the breakfast is second to none. We look forward to returning in the future.

Patrick Pavlick2 weeks ago

5/5

We stayed here due to the Jupiter Ballon Festival at Conner Prairie. Not only was the location perfect, but the well appointed rooms, amenities, service, and food were as well. Thanks for wonderful weekend stay!

Cheryl Heitz2 weeks ago

5/5

What a remarkable accommodation. I can’t say enough good things about our accommodations ….. except we are looking for things happening near this bed and breakfast just to be able to stay there again! Thank you so much for creating such a relaxing accommodating place

Tricia Wells3 weeks ago

5/5

Prairie Guest House was the most beautiful and classy/comfortable BnB I have ever experienced. It had great charming details in every room. A perfect place to stay to get away and enjoy the sincere hospitality of the owners. Thank you

Katherine Boyum3 weeks ago

5/5

Had such a refreshing stay at Prairie Guest House! The location is convenient, Karen and Brooke were so kind and hospitable, the room was perfectly cozy, and the breakfast - the BREAKFAST. It was absolutely delicious. Thank you for a wonderful experience!

View all reviews

Property info

13805 Allisonville Rd, Fishers, IN 46038

stay@prairieguesthouse.com

317-663-8728

The Journal — Fishers

All stories

Relax at One of the Best Places to Stay near Indianapolis

If you're looking for a fun adventure, consider staying at one of the best places to stay near Indianapolis and joining us for some adventur…

Read On